Newman Smith had 21 singers audition on the first round and 14 of them will be advancing to the next round on October 15. The following students will be advancing:
| Jamie Bottomley | 11th | S1 |
| Aden Black | 10th | S2 |
| Sierra Davis | 12th | S2 |
| Lamisa Mustafa | 12th | A1 |
| Morgen Amalbert | 12th | A2 |
| Natasha Duke | 11th | A2 |
| Wiley Dodge | 12th | T1 |
| Alejandro Aguilar | 11th | T1 |
| Carlos Torres | 12th | T2 |
| Cesar Ramos | 11th | T2 |
| Sergio Lopez | 11th | T2 |
| Rami Bakr | 10th | B1 |
| Miguel Morales | 12th | B2 |
| David Lasater | 10th | B2 |